“We…we…don’t tell Rachel please,” I said pleading to Maddie. I was shaking and I quickly got on my knees pleading that she kept quiet that Savannah and I fucked.
Maddie crossed her arms, she was wearing an off shoulder crop top with a white skirt and black wedge heeled sandals. She also had some eye liner and lip gloss on like she was going out.
“Why are you dressed like that?” Savannah asked as if she had read my mind.
“Oh im going to another party, I’ll be back in a couple I’m just going there to chill, I would say you can come, but it looks like you are too busy,” Maddie said and then dropped some items from her bag off.
“I’m leaving my shit here cause I won’t be long. By the way, I have some morning after pills in case his pull out game is weak,” Maddie stated and quickly left the house before I could throw a comeback at her.
“So….” I said awkwardly.
“Wanna fuck?” She asked.
“I don’t know I’m a little tired and what if Maddie tells Rachel I’m still scared,” I said worried of what might happen.
“She won’t I promise ill tell her right now,” Savannah said as she grabbed her phone and quickly texted her and told me, “Maddie says you owe her.”
“Alright well I guess it is okay,” I said.
She grabbed the lube and started putting it on. She grabbed my cock and started stroking it.
“Wow I hardly touched you and you’re already hard,” she said surprised. I was happy I got to fuck her again, and now we could go at it nonstop. After I was hard she slowly climbed on top of me while I was laying back on the couch, she slowly grabbed my cock and put it deep into her pussy. She grabbed me by shoulders and started burying her nails deep into my shoulders. We started going slow but picked up a little speed, and soon she was going up and down in a rhythm on my cock.
“So are we going to do this often?” she asked me innocently.
“I don’t know, do you want to then I guess…” I said and then I was interrupted
“Hell yeah I want it,” Savannah said lustfully. She looked at me, her gaze shot with desire for pleasure, pleasure that I could give her. I agreed to do this, cheating on my girlfriend to please Savannah.
“You better not tell Rachel,” I said to her, as I thrusted hardly into her just to change up the sex. I grabbed her by her ass and started spanking her a little; she let out some soft moans and then kissed me, passionately, she forcefully put her tongue inside my mouth and started going on my tongue I immediately met my tongue with hers and soon it was my tongue in her mouth. Soon we parted lips and my eyes turned to her beautiful small but round breasts.
I massaged…no I caressed them and stimulated her breasts by grabbing her petite pink precious nipples and moving them around and pulling them, stimulating this beautiful girl that was letting me make love to her.
“Ohh that feels so good, fuckkkk, suck on them please!” Savannah screamed as she was nearing her climax. I quickly sat up and got her on top of me and grabbed her by the ass while my mouth focused on sucking her breasts, and I continued to use my tongue and flicked them a couple of times. As I pumped my cock into her tight pussy and played with her breasts, she finally had enough. Savannah screamed from the top of her lungs and began to moan loudly as she reached her climax.
For a while we both lay there naked. At that moment I regretted everything. I had Rachel, the most beautiful woman in the world and I somehow traded that for Savannah, the sexiest woman in the world. We both lay there not saying a word, and I see her still panting heavily with cum dripping from her pussy. I can’t help but look at her and marvel at such a hot girl. She then, without a word goes to Maddie’s’ bag and takes out a pill, goes to the kitchen to get some water and takes the pill, effectively making sure that no child grows from this betrayal.
I got up and fixed everything in the room. Making sure it looked normal. She went upstairs and I heard the water of a shower run.
“Want to join me?” she asked playfully but slowly as she was tired from having sex.
“No,” I returned nonchalantly knowing I had made a mistake. I said nothing and went to get my stuff and returned home.
I arrived at school and went to where Rachel usually hangs out. I saw her wearing black leggings and a tight blue shirt. I enjoyed looking at her tight ass, so fat in the right places I went to grab her by the waist and kissed her on the cheek. Her large group of friends continued to speak and I just saw my beautiful girlfriends blush and smile as I embraced her. I also saw a couple of jocks looking at us as well and asked her what it was about. It was her ex’s boyfriends checking to see if she was in need of a man taking care of her.
“They are fucking pervs!” she yelled quietly in my ear.
“Just ignore them angel,” I said as I looked at her cherubic face.
“Make them jealous,” she said and then quickly said, “Grab my butt.”
I wasted no time and grabbed hold of her ass. I wanted to make love to it right then and there, but I just caressed it, moving her cheeks apart and letting them go back into place, I could feel her thong so slim, and almost nonexistent. Her friends had no idea what was going on and those jocks were jealous of me and kept looking knowing that Rachel, the most gorgeous girl alive was mine and mine alone.
“…so yeah, Christian, Rachel are you okay with that?” one of the girls asked us.
“Rachel, who paid more attention than I did said yes, yes to what?
“Alright so movies at 8,” Savannah said and looked at me.
I whispered in her ear, “I thought we were going to spend some time alone in your house?” I asked knowing we had sex planned for today.
“Come by earlier,” she said happily as we heard the bell ring and we marched to class. It was now Chemistry and my best friend and I were talking, Maddie was the only girl from Rachel’s’ group who knew what happened. We were doing a lab mixing stuff together and Maddie was looking through the corner of her eye at me. I did not want to say anything and neither did she. We just kept looking. I’ll be honest Maddie was a short girl with beautiful white skin, her nose was a little big, but an appealing face that led to two petite breasts and a flat stomach ultimately what brought everyone to her attention was her ass, it was big and plump, just the way I like it, her feet were nice painted purple and treated very well, they were appealing to say the least and I looked at her ass again, almost like Rachel’s except she had a perkier butt and it gyrated a lot when she moved which made it completely attractive and entrancing.
“Christian and Maddie, please come here for a second.” We heard the teacher call us.
We both went up to her desk for a couple of minutes and we both looked really nervous.
“Christian, you know Maddie right?” she asked me, to which I nodded and said “Yes.”
“Well Maddie here has had some trouble with molecular models and she asked me if I had someone to help her to and since you understand this, you can maybe do me the favor of helping her, and in return ill throw in some extra credit points on that other test.
I stammered a little, but ultimately I agreed to do it.
“Alright after school meet here and I’ll be here to make sure you both know what to do. Our teacher said.
It did not dawn on me that after school I was going to go to Rachel’s house. I was double booked, and I either had to let down my girlfriend or let down my teacher. Keep in mind, I’m a nerd so this is very important for me.
“Don’t worry, Rachel will be double booked as well. Victoria Secret is having a 7 for $27 special and no girl will be able to resist that.”
“So why are you not going?” I asked curiously.
She then motioned her hands for me to move closer and whispered in my ear “I don’t usually use underwear.”
We both stood there for a second and said nothing. She then smiled knowing I was shocked why she was so open about that and she began to walk away. I knew that she wanted me and I couldn’t let her get the last laugh not after last night. The bell had rung and everyone was leaving, suddenly I get a text from Rachel.
“Hey Christian, sorry I won’t be at my house I have to buy some stuff at VS, don’t worry I’ll let you see what I bought just come by around 6 so we can hang out for an hour”
I had some time to kill and school was over. Maddie stayed at her seat patiently and our teacher just sat down and gave us the rundown about how to prepare her for the next test.
We work on what she does not understand and go from there. I actually think she learned something, eventually the teacher leaves the room and we are left alone and I become emboldened by my previous sexual experiences. I needed her to stand up to grab her ass. I wanted to feel it. I asked her to throw a piece of paper away as we are near a trash can and she does. She comes back to sit down, but like a hawk I watch her, observing her gyrating ass in motion with no panties on. I finally see the opportunity and launch my plan, I go in for a slap on her ass, but my hand goes in for a grope, grasping this nice butt.
“Wow, ummmm this is awkward,” Maddie blushed as she thought of me as someone who did not have enough balls to do what I wanted.
“This is what you wanted.” I shot back.
“Well umm…” She was beginning to stutter and at this moment I went up to her and kissed her, using my tongue to probe her mouth. She seemed to enjoy it as she moaned rather loudly. We kissed for about 30 seconds, our lips electrifying each other with stimuli, both of us enjoying twirling our tongues in a small but delicate dance. We pulled away and she got on the table, on all fours with her booty looking at me. I immediately pulled off her leggings and saw her tight teen pussy hole and after prying her cheeks open I saw a small tight asshole winking at me. I began to kiss her butt cheeks, slowly stimulating her and going toward her love hole that was like a waterfall. My head was buried deep in her pussy in a few seconds and I ate out of her hole slowly because I wanted to savor this moment. She tasted so good and for a long time I wanted to fuck her. My tongue began going in and out of her pussy her moans kept low so that no one could hear. We could hear voices and we immediately decided to stop and she pulled up her leggings and we acted as if nothing had happened.
“So kids, how was the studying been?” our teacher asked us.
“Its gone great actually! I think I get it!” Maddie exclaimed as she was a little sweaty from holding it in.
“Well do you feel you finished?” I asked, hoping she would catch my drift.
“No, I want more, do you mind coming over to my house and helping me?” she asked curiously.
“Yeah!” I said happily.
Our teacher then collected her work and said “Alright, since your helping her out of school too I guess we can postpone the test for her, maybe a day or so.”
Our teacher said.
She then continued, “And you Christian, you won’t take the test, instead you will get whatever grade she gets, plus your extra credit.”
We both nodded and happily left. She started walking ahead of me, meanwhile I texted Rachel making sure she was not home yet. She quickly responded and said 40 minutes. I have 40 minutes to get to Maddie’s home and fuck while Rachel gets here. I go behind Maddie and grope her butt, she seemed to not care and we kept on walking.
“So, what are you going to do to me when I get home?” She asked seductively, as if she didn’t know already.
“Oh you’ll see.’ I fired back. We got into her car and drove off; I put my hand between her thighs and could feel her wetness seeping through.
“So who was better out of the three of us?” Maddie asked out of nowhere.
“Why do you ask?” I questioned hoping these types of questions wouldn’t come up.
“Well I’m just curious, I mean which of the two did you prefer? I mean Rachel told us you had your first time with her and well…? She trailed off not knowing how to explain it.
“Well I definitely love Rachel, she made it amazing, she just has something about her that was beautiful when we were making love. She knew what she was doing, and kind of guided me.” I said reminiscing on my first time with Rachel, imaging her beautiful skin lain bare on her bed and me kissing her and grabbing her body.
“What about Savannah?” she then inquired.
“Savannah just is more comfortable sexually speaking and she was more experienced, but I did not feel a connection with her,” I said trying to keep it brief as we turned the corner into a neighborhood.
“How did I compare with the time you had with me?” she asked shyly but boldly.
“Well, I love Rachel and Savannah was a pro, but you’re pretty attractive and umm, well we didn’t get that far.” I said trying to seem like she was bad but still be truthful. She remained silent until we got to her house. We got out of the car and I marveled at the size of it as she opened the door. Maddie grabbed hold on my hand and led me to her room where we sat in silence.
For about a minute or so we stood there and finally she broke the silence.
“Well… are you going to continue?” She asked eagerly.
“Yeah, but wait how am I going to get home?” I asked realizing I left my car at school.
“Oh don’t worry I told Rachel you were going to be here while you were texting her and she said ok, we are just meeting up here and then going to the movies.” She explained calming me down.
“So shall we?” she asked as she was now on her bed sitting in a position where her ass was in full view.
I slowly made my way toward the bed and groped her ass. I slowly kissed her neck making her moan to my kisses. Rubbing her ass, she then pulled down her leggings which were easy to get. I made my way slowly to her pussy where I began picking up where I had left off. She was still into it, moaning at every movement my tongue made. Oh God she is so tight, I think as she spreads her legs so I can go even deeper. I pulled away from her clit and kissed her passionately, putting my tongue in her mouth. She sucks back on my tongue just the same way Savannah sucked my cock. Damn!. S We both stop for a moment and look at each other realizing we probably should start fucking before Rachel gets here.
She spread her legs wide enough for me to get between them and started rubbing herself. She was nervous but eager. I slowly thrusted inside and as soon as I touched her she began screaming and moaning. Her face was turning red as if I was causing her pain. I realized why that was when she began bleeding from her pussy. She was a virgin.
“Wait you’re a virgin!” I yelled loudly in surprise and my thrusting stopped. Had I known she was a virgin I would have taken it slower. I paused and let her catch her breath. Then I wondered why she had those morning after pills.
“Hey wait why did you have the morning after pills if you are a virgin?” I asked while she calmed down and didn’t feel any pain.
“It…was…for a friend.” She panted as she felt the pain subside. “You feel good inside of me.” She said as she threw a smile at the end of the sentence.
I slowly picked up speed, letting her get used to me inside of her. I began thrusting in and out and she out some high pitched moans but not as bad as before. She seemed to enjoy it.
“Oh fuck…fuck…fuck…fuck… Christian please go faster!” She screamed as I began picking up speed.
I then went as fast as I could fulfilling her wish, trying to make her first time pleasant.
“Im cumming!” she screamed as she was about to climax.
As if we were synchronized, we both came. My cum went deep inside her pussy and began dripping from her pussy as I pulled my cock out of her love hole.
“My orgasm was intense, I only given myself one while I was playing with myself,” she explained after a couple minutes of her recovering.
“We should probably get cleaned up before Rachel and Savannah show up to your door.” I said sweating heavily.
“Yeah they should be here in 5 minutes. Let’s take a shower before they show up so we don’t smell like sex.” Maddie said as she got me a towel.
“There is a guest room next door, use that bathroom in there, quickly” Maddie added.
We both got up and began to go to our respective bathrooms. I went directly to the bathroom and quickly got into it hoping to get the stench of sex off of me.
While In the shower I swear I could hear Maddie play with herself. Then unfortunately I thought of all the bad things I had done. I cheated on Rachel, the most beautiful girl, with Maddie the cutest girl. I knew I had to have more sex with Rachel to solidify our relationship and maybe do something special for her, after the movie I’ll go to her house and make passionate love to her rather than having sex with these two girls, but I know that there is more to come between Savannah and I and Maddie and I. I will have to deal with these relationships, but I know in my heart and mind I love Rachel.
After my shower I got dressed in the same clothes and made my way downstairs to the living room and waited for Maddie to join me. I got on my phone, scrolled through twitter and patiently waited for Rachel to get here.
Maddie then joined me of course, she looked happy but said nothing. Instead we both sat in her lavish living room in hush. The doorbell ranged and I went to open it, I saw the most beautiful woman there was, Rachel standing there. I hugged her rapidly almost launching myself at her. She seemed surprised and I looked her in the eye and gave her a passionate kiss. I continue hugging her and whispered “I missed you beautiful”
We both stood there hugging each other for about a minute.
“So are we going to the movies?” Savannah asked. We just laughed and went to the car; Savannah and Maddie were in the front while Rachel and I were in the back. During the ride we talked about how her day went, and what she did, the whole ride I held her hand and kissed her a few times. She seemed astonished that I missed her that much.
When we arrived at the movie theater I put my hand over her waist the entire walk to the entrance, everyone who walked by noticed how happy we looked as if we were newlyweds. I kissed her cheek quickly and she blushed as bystanders marveled at how happy we were. We asked Savannah and Maddie to take some cute pictures of us outside to show our affection. They of course put on a smile and obliged. I don’t know what they feel at the moment, but I know I love Rachel and that’s all that matters.
Authors Notes: Part 4 is coming. I’m going to add a couple new characters that will bring a change to the story. I have a plan for a couple new girls and a few guys, people that won’t be sexualized but will serve as drivers for the plot Part 4 will definitely be longer than this and you should not expect it to be done within the week. Don’t worry Savannah and Maddie still be having sex with Christian; they might just have to be a bit forceful. Please When you finish reading this tell me what you like and what you did not like and where you want to see the characters and sex go next.
